I turned in arwen and the glass shoe quest and it gave me the xp i was able to accept and complete it again immediately afterwards
yea i know, it wasnt taking the shoes I just dont want to get banned for an exploit so i figured id report it. if you think that its working okay then good.
I believe it says it's taking the shoe, but it's really not. The quest can thus be turned in over and over, without losing the shoe.
I logged out to make a thread, i realized i had a crappy screenshot and when i logged back in the shoe was indeed gone. I figured rather be safe than sorry though.