Haven't seen anyone make a thread regarding this yet. Last year's rewards were really awesome chairs and alotta candies. However, I've done it 67 times for this year's on Hard Mode but aside from the default first time completion prize Spooky Bath Chair and 15 tokens, I've only got lollipops and peppermints. I will continue to update if I get any new rewards. It would also be nice if you share what you got here so we know what the prizes pool look like. I'm getting diabetes from all these candies.
Last year, I did 7 characters every time the cd was off. Got like 5 full moon chairs, 3 winner podium effects and 3 zombie hunter hats in 2 bloody weeks. Rates are definitely low.
People with proof of something other than the guaranteed chair, lollipops or peppermints being rewarded for completing hardmode, please step right up! Was not expecting to get anything myself this soon.. but when it seems noone has got anything so far you cant help but wonder if you're wasting your time
Just like how they added more stuffs to the Dark Token list, I feel that it is still possible to change it and encourage more people to do the jump quest, if the GMs would just look at how the rewards can be improved... at this point we are almost sure that we are just getting those candies
Its still a decent way to build up tokens if you get proficient enough to clear it fast. But it would just be nice to know if the chance is there or if they completely remade the reward pool.