Closed Shoutbox ban

Discussion in 'Ban Appeal' started by Melkweg, Nov 25, 2023.

  1. Melkweg
    Offline

    Melkweg Well-Known Member

    All Your Character Names: this forum account
    Last thing you did: was banned for a while
    Why do you think you got banned?: probably drama on shoutbox
    Ban message when attempting to log in: none
    What GM banned you (optional): Dave

    My forum ban was lifted.
    Still can't see shoutbox I assume I still banned there. Would like to get some info about this ban.
     
    Last edited: Nov 25, 2023
  2. Dave Deviluke
    Offline

    Dave Deviluke Forum Moderator

  3. Bacon
    Offline

    Bacon GM

    Hello. We have decided to lift your shoutbox ban. Please note, if you join in on inciting flame wars in the future through the shoutbox, or violate any other forum rules through the shoutbox, your next shoutbox ban will be permanent.
     
  4. Melkweg
    Offline

    Melkweg Well-Known Member

    Was that a permaban until I appeal for that?
     
  5. Dave Deviluke
    Offline

    Dave Deviluke Forum Moderator

    All shoutbox bans are permanent until appealed + lifted
     
  6. Melkweg
    Offline

    Melkweg Well-Known Member

    So here comes to question when it cannot be lifted?
    It's pretty grey area with the rules.
    What rules applies on the decision whether lift the ban or remain permanent?
     
  7. Dave Deviluke
    Offline

    Dave Deviluke Forum Moderator

    That sounds like you are planning on doing something in shoutbox, are you?

    Not sure if you noticed, shoutbox ban appeals aren't that common
    We only issue shoutbox ban if we deem it necessary
     
  8. Melkweg
    Offline

    Melkweg Well-Known Member

    Nobody asked you to make assumptions ban me for based evidence not for what I might sounds like.
    It's for the massive report about what happened there before I got banned.
    I disagree with another person unban which makes me think why did I got ban.
    All I can think off out of the conversation at that time is false accusation which is not against the rules.
    Which made me to ban evade to collect more evidence against those I wanna report.
    What reason I got banned for? I would like the specific phrase I wrote that cause my the ban please.
     
  9. Dave Deviluke
    Offline

    Dave Deviluke Forum Moderator

    You were not banned for disagreeing with someone else's unban or ban

    You were banned for making flaming comments on Shoutbox, hence please do not flame on Shoutbox anymore and submit a proper report
    https://royals.ms/forum/forums/reports.7/create-thread

    The 20 WP issued were given due to your ban evades (2), not related to your shoutbox ban
    Anyone else who ban-evade or multi-forum can be subjected to 20 WP as well
     
  10. Melkweg
    Offline

    Melkweg Well-Known Member

    So did I got shoutbox & forum banned for making flaming comments on shoutbox?
     
  11. Dave Deviluke
    Offline

    Dave Deviluke Forum Moderator

    Will be including Hebrew text as well, as you seem to be misunderstanding my replies

    You were banned from Shoutbox because of the heated comments
    נאסרתם מ-Shoutbox בגלל התגובות הסוערות

    You created 2 more forum accounts to "gather evidence" in the shoutbox you no longer have access to - which would be a form of evasion of the original ban
    יצרת עוד 2 חשבונות פורום כדי "לאסוף ראיות" בתיבת הצעקות שכבר אין לך גישה אליה - מה שתהיה סוג של התחמקות מהאיסור המקורי

    You got 20 WP (warning points) for each ban evading
    קיבלת 20 WP (נקודות אזהרה) על כל התחמקות מהחסימה

    You have not been issued any WP (Warning Points) for the comments posted
    לא הונפקו לך שום WP (נקודות אזהרה) על ההערות שהועלו
     
  12. Melkweg
    Offline

    Melkweg Well-Known Member

    I completely understood. It's seems you are the actual one who misunderstood me.
    I was ban evading in order to gather evidence in first place because I was shoutbox AND FORUM banned.

    Why did I got the forum ban in first place? If I only got banned for flaming from shoutbox.

    I will mention it again : I BAN EVADED AFTER FORUM BAN
    Shouldnt I suppose to be banned from shoutbox only?
    YES OR NO?
     
  13. Dave Deviluke
    Offline

    Dave Deviluke Forum Moderator

    I think you have remembered the order of events wrongly

    1. You were initially only given a shoutbox ban (0 WP issued)
    2. You wanted to access Shoutbox again so you created 2nd forum
    3. I banned your 2nd forum permanently and gave your main forum 20 WP
    4. Your main forum was in a 3-day ban due to 20 WP given
    5. You ban evaded again with the 3rd forum
    6. I banned your 3rd forum permanently and gave your main forum 20 WP again (40 WP in total)
    7. Your main forum was in a 7-day ban due to 20 WP given (40 WP in total)
    Your main profile forum's ban (40 WP) was a result of your ban-evading, you were not issued any other additional WP

    As per your forum profile, you only have 40 WP (from the 2 x ban-evading)
    [​IMG]
     

Share This Page