From what I've seen, generally this only gets a moderate 14 day infraction when key weighting, and anything more advanced (macros, or vaguely plausible sounding excuses for totally not using macros) is upgraded to major. I recommend splitting this into robotic play (major infraction) and key weighting (moderate infraction) for clarity. I don't think any of the actual punishments would need to change - the current severity seems appropriate
Probably somewhat on this topic but a clerification about what being attentive to the game mean would also be nice. For example, is it ok to not look at the client screen at all but look at a different client in the same map? is it ok if you could only see the chat etc.