Agree, you forgot the 10-20k NX also drop from HT, that worth like a lot if people use this NX to gach and get good stuff. People benefit a lot from HT while CWKPQ is only for the mask, and yet, HT is an end-game boss but the min level to enter is lvl 80 ~~ People could easy buy that service to have lots of benefit. This isn't fair!
It doesnt need godly stats going from 11 +5 to make it 16 att, it should honestly stay the way it is, 11 att max and keep the +5 on the ap stat roll for the +11, but it honestly does not need to be nerfed down to 8. Even though its a decent compromise, iI still think this item should not be nerfed and just kept at its 11 att max *11 being godly*
After MoN/CWKPQ released in GMS with MoN being 8~12 attack clean, people still HT daily for HTP buyers, and endless demand of HT books. In GMS even months after MoN came out people still buy HTP at 600m. Keeping in mind 600m in GMS is probably 1.2b or more in MapleRoyals with respect of the market and mesos' buying power, the higher drop/mesos rate, and free nx income everyday. Looking from the MapleRoyals washing culture perspective. HTP+egg will be ideal for people who wants to reach high HP since it gives 21~28 INT. TLDR: Keeping MoN the way it is without nerfing won't make HT irrelevant since CWKPQ and HT serve the community differently. It's already proven in GMS.