I turned in ingredients to Grandma Benson 10 times but I never got any pop up that NPC Duey had the Pumpkin Pie Ring for me
I don't think the ring is from Duey, only the guild chairs. I got my pie ring from grandma benson after a certain number of turn-ins.
After I turned in 10 I was expecting the ring directly from Grandma Benson but the event post said that we'd get them from Duey once the event was over
Seems like a miscommunication from staff because this is contrary to my experience (that I didn't get the ring from Duey, but I got it when I turned in 10 pies from Grandma Benson and I did get the guild chairs from Duey), but I rechecked the event post and it says: "If you help Grandma Benson 10 or more times with baking pies, you will be rewarded with a pumpkin pie ring. The ring will be sent to your character via NPC Duey after the event ends." https://royals.ms/forum/threads/thanksgiving-2023.225944/#post-1380725 Still does not explain how she doesn't have the ring though.