summing up your entire history does not add up to the advances you made in your gear upgrades and ways of earning mesos especially regarding: - AP resets you would need to wash to 15.3k hp on your BM and 19.8k on your paladin when you claim to frequent gachapon so much that you pull 5 bwg in august but also frequently gachapon for ws/cs - receiving high valued items in 2020 (22 BWG and 119 concerto) from a player that hasnt logged in since 2019 due to their RWT ban - meso income based on bossing on two characters, a bm and a paldin, dont cover all the expensive scrolling attempts you took part in especially since they also come with a cost of attack potions like onyx apples while the trades, upgrades and downgrades you listed happened, not all of the white and chaos scrolls you had your hands on for scrolling attempts and trades seem to be obtained by legitimate means leaving you permanently banned for real world trade
Well, First of all, I wont gonna lie and say I'm pretty much disappointment with this decision of closing the appeal without letting me response or say anything back to clear this allegedly misleading information you wrote.... - As I said earlier in the appeal and you can check it yourself (which I am extremely surprised you haven't yet), I rarely USED APR for my HP gain! (I was leveling up without int/int gear or knew about the washing procedure), I was doing HP quest daily for over year! you can EVEN see my HP slowly rise from all my screenshot over the years when I already reached 200.... So yea, I mainly used my NX for gachapon purposes, and less for APRs, I'd say 75%~25% ratio - Yes, as you questioning me before, I did got the Concerto and 22 BWG from Shazamy who later got banned from soliciting with RWT & as I said earlier in this thread, I wasn't questioning his legitimacy since I knew him IRL, I got his Item from 1 of his many characters IGN: RealRawGarry, without the knowledge of being ban from RWT. I'm sure some of his many characters are still accessible right now and the only reason you don't know is because he haven't logged in on them because he just quit 2+ years ago. And I will say it again, I would have not taken the items if I knew they are "in bad-blood". - Moreover, I never said that "meso income based on bossing on two characters, a bm and a paldin..." bossing was my source of income, Heck, I even said "that not what's make you rich in this game..." My income was from Calculated, Successful, Luck-Involvement scrolling detailed in the big 10, I very detailly explained and even elaborated the math so that anyone can calculate himself, I made it as simple as possible so that any Average Joe can pull-up his calculator and check it out, which you did confirmed and checked: "the trades, upgrades and downgrades you listed happened", yet your previous writing allegedly say I didn't acquire my wealth fair and square , which leave me confused & wonder to myself, why would you write it in the first place other than overshadow my honest achievements? Lastly, You claim "not all of the white and chaos scrolls you had your hands on for scrolling attempts and trades seem to be obtained by legitimate means", which I beg the differ! I claim that ALL my scrolls were acquired by legitimate manner, and traded with honest players, & you even questioning me this in private conversation & I answered you I haven't traded with anyone who looked shady, or seemed/behaved suspiciously. Since you are the Admin, you can tell and see all my trades & with whom I traded, and I ask you again, check all my trade history and tell me where I did wrong and with whom I traded that backs up this claim of me getting scrolls in illegitimately manner? I ask the Staff & You to re-open this appeal, from all the reasons above, and re-discuss and continue your investigation, because condemning me wrongly is just Not fair and pure Unjust. sincerely, Disco Stu.
Good evening, @Matt @Tim or any Admin/Staff member, Have you read my comment on your sentences? I think my reasoning should not be dismissed so easily and I think I deserve a comment or a chance to respond on your decisive (and may I say even Harsh,) judgment by closing this appeal without lettings me respond to your statements. It is not Fair nor Just to do so and I gave plenty of evidence/information & my view of the case, and I'm innocent. Unless you just want me to give up by prolonging this saga and make me frustrated, I don't see why my case shouldn't be re-opened again, considered my reply on each & everyone of your statements/claims. sincerely, Disco Stu.
Hello, Have you looked at my response? I would expect the management of this server to have the decency just to say "Yes, we have" Sincerely, Disco Stu.
Hello, May I get any reasoning why my response hasn't changed the outcome of my ban appeal, since I basically gave an explanation why each of your 3 claims is either incorrect or not right/just by default? - I haven't HP wash (was doing HP quest daily for a year+), yet you wrongly say I have. - I clearly said my income was not from bossing but from scrolling (& gave a detailed dated explanations, screenshots & some videos), yet you just write this awful claim down like paint on a stencil. - receiving high valued items from a friend (which I did not know at the time was rwt) who got banned on 1 (or even more, I don't even know anymore) of his chars, yet I gave you the name of the IGN of his char I got it from at 2020 ("RealRawGarry" I believe, which is probably not banned even now I bet). You have even confirmed all my trades and saw how I got my income, yet you claim me to be a rwt scum.... I would like to request, yet again, a re-open on my appeal or just a real, coherent justification why not to, since your claims are not solid nor correct in any way. Sincerely, Disco Stu.
I am sorry to say this, but myself and a few other Staff members have tried bumping this Appeal many times over it's duration. There is no telling when or if this Appeal will ever get another response by an Admin but nonetheless I have asked for a follow up regardless. I am sorry about the wait and the frustration that comes along with it.
Greetings @Becca , thank you for the response, I guess all I need to do is just keep waiting? If anything can be done by any of the Staff members, I'll sure do appreciate it very much. Sincerely, Disco Stu.
Hello, your appeal was denied twice already, as mentioned in the previous posts. There wouldn't be any update on it anymore
