@sammycool I see a big issue with implementing a Island PQ requiring 3-6 people. It's already hard enough to gather a group for KPQ and sometimes CPQ, let alone that many on just beginner island. I know that in order to keep a party quest true to it's name, you'll need a party, but maybe lower it to 2-3 people instead? I just don't think that the islander population is large enough for a 3-6 person requirement.
My time on maple island has made me wish for a cape to use all these cape scrolls on. An overall would be nice as well--as 10% overall dex scrolls are available on the island--but that may be pushing it. A PQ is definitely my top request!
I dont get this business about "maple island should stay a challange" .. I never once implied that the PQ would be an easier way of leveling, infact I even stated that I wouldnt mind it giving NO EXP WHATSOEVER as long as some items are there to compensate. If exp were to be given, it would be roughly the same amount an islander can receive from grinding.
Ever thought that the PQ would bring more islanders? And besides, it makes it more enjoyable if you cant do it 100% of the time, it means that the grinding side of islanding can still be and will be an option and the PQ side a treat.